facade Commerzbank Düsseldorf
Renovating Modern Heritage

The Upgraded Façade of Commerzbank Düsseldorf

Authors

Downloads

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47982/jfde.2022.powerskin.4

Keywords:

facade renovation, reuse, retrofitting, aluminium curtain wall, Josef Gartner GmbH, modern building heritage conservation

Abstract

The post-war building stock is increasingly being transformed. Even at objects protected as listed heritage, renovation usually results in a high degree of material exchange and replacement. This is especially the case in regard to historic curtain wall constructions. Based on the case study of the Commerzbank High-rise and original planning documents by Gartner, the paper focuses on the applied strategy of disassembling and reassembling the curtained aluminium sandwich elements, and the resulting upgrading of the original façade with a newly installed interlayer for insulation. The paper discusses the possible transfer of this strategy, which largely depended on the existing high quality of the aluminium components, their corrosion-resistant properties and low weight. The case study of the former Commerzbank High-rise indicates that a long-term preservation of post-war modern building stock can be achieved without wholesale replacement of original building components. The reuse of existing materials and components represents a promising approach.

How to Cite

Grom, R. S., & Putz, A. W. (2022). Renovating Modern Heritage: The Upgraded Façade of Commerzbank Düsseldorf. Journal of Facade Design and Engineering, 10(2), 57–70. https://doi.org/10.47982/jfde.2022.powerskin.4

Published

2022-12-06

References

Aluminium-Zentrale e.V. (1959). Aluminium-Fassaden. Bericht der Aluminium-Zentrale e.V. Band 5 [Aluminium-Façades. Review of the Aluminium-Zentrale e.V. Volume 5]. Düsseldorf, MA: Aluminium-Zentrale e.V..

Ayon, A., Pottgiesser, U., Richards, N. (2019). Neue Fassaden im Bestand. Sanierungsstrategien für Klassiker der Moderne [New facades in existing building stock. Renovation strategies of modern classics]. Birkhäuser Verlag GmbH.

Fürst, T. M. (1998). Das Thyssen-Haus in Düsseldorf: Die Modernisierung eines Nachkriegsmonuments [The Thyssen-House in Düsseldorf: The Modernization of a post-war monument]. Conservation of Modern Architecture? ICOMOS Journals of the German National Committee XXIV, 77–89.

Gartner, Dr. F. (2021). Interview 27.05.2021.

Gockell, B. (1964). Über die Verwendung von vorgehängten Fassaden (Curtain Walls) in gestalterischer, konstruktiver und technischer Hinsicht [About the usage of curtain walls in terms of design, construction and technology]. (Doctoral Dissertation).

Grom, R. (2021). Findbuch Josef Gartner (1955–1985). [Inventory Josef Gartner (1955-1985)] Unpublished study, funded by Wüstenrot Stiftung.

Hoffmann, K., Griese, H., & Meyer-Bohe, W. (1975). Fassaden. Die Bauelemente V [Façades. The Building Components V]. Stuttgart, MA: Julius Hoffmann.

de Jonge, W. (2017) Sustainable renewal of the everyday Modern, Journal of Architectural Conservation, 23:1-2, 62-105, DOI: 10.1080/13556207.2017.1326555

Josef Gartner GmbH. (2016). Sanierung Fassade Commerzbank Düsseldorf [Renovating façade Commerzbank Düsseldorf]. Unpublished internal study.

Kuipers, M. (2017). Van Nellefabriek Rotterdam: World Heritage of a World Port. MA: nai010 publishers.

Lepik, A., & Heß, R. (2015). Paul Schneider Esleben. Architekt [Paul Schneider Esleben. Architect]. Hatje Cantz.

Meurs, P., & van Thoor, M. (2010). Sanatorium Zonnestraal. History and Restoration of a Modern Monument. NAi Publishers.

Roming, M. (2022). Discussion and E-Mail 07.03.2022.

Roming, M., & Rothkopf, C. (2022). Revitalisierung Commerzbank Düsseldorf. Sanierung einer denkmalgeschützten Hochhausfassade [Revitalization of Commerzbank Düsseldorf. Refurbishment of a listed high-rise façade]. FASSADE / FAÇADE: Fachzeitschrift für Fenster- und Fassadenbau / Revue technique pour fenetres et façades, 02, 45-50.

Rung, H., & Putz, A. (2021). Potentialanalyse des Bauvolumens von Bürohochhäusern (1950 – 80) [Potential analysis of the construction volume of high-rise office buildings (1950 - 80)]. Unpublished study. Funded by Stiftung Bayerisches Baugewerbe.

Schaal, R. (1961). Vorhangwände. Curtain Walls. Typen Konstruktionsarten Gestaltung [Curtain Walls. Design Manual]. Georg D. W. Callwey.

Schneider-Esleben, P. (1963). Verwaltungshochhaus der Commerzbank, Düsseldorf = Bâtiment administratif de la Commerzbank à Düsseldorf = Administrative building of the Commerzbank, Düsseldorf. Bauen + Wohnen = Construction + habitation = Building + home : internationale Zeitschrift, 17(8), 344-347. doi:10.5169/seals-331661

Sulzer, P. (1991). Jean Prouvé : Meister der Metallumformung ; das neue Blech [Jean Prouvé : Master of metalforming ; the new sheat metal]. Rudolf Müller GmbH.